Misleading Democratic Ad in Nevada on ‘Sunsetting Medicare and Social Security’

” I believe I appreciate that he’s trying to look onward. He’s attempting to cast a favorable vision,” Brown said of Scott. “Among the important things I think that a few of our Republican Event leaders have fallen short at is that we have come to be identified, and occasionally we do this to ourselves, as the event of no. ‘Oh, no, we’re not going to do that.’ You recognize? We’re the party of simply turning down policy as opposed to the event of projecting ideas, and what Rick Scott has carried out in attempting to produce a roadmap for a much better America is something that I appreciate as well.”

The Rosen campaign has a factor that Brown has supported reducing government investing in ways that specialists caution would certainly place preferred programs at threat. The campaign’s proof included a Nevada Present article last month concerning Brown claiming he could sustain regulation that would reduce the government budget plan by 1% in succeeding years in an effort to stabilize the budget.

The ad, which was released earlier this month by Sen. Jacky Rosen’s project, describes comments that Brown made in February 2022 about Sen. Rick Scott’s “11-Point Strategy to Rescue America.” Scott developed the strategy as a roadmap for governing if the Republicans took control of Congress after the 2022 midterm political elections. At the time, Brown was running in Nevada’s Republican politician primary for U.S. Us senate– a race that he shed to previous state Attorney General Paul Laxalt.

While he did state it is “very sensible” to reduce federal investing annually by 1%, Brown did not say which programs he would certainly reduce and did not state Social Safety and Medicare in all. The lack of specificity is a fundamental problem with Paul’s regulation and his efforts to pass such a strategy in Congress, according to the nonpartisan Board for a Responsible Federal Budget Plan.

Paul himself has actually stated that Medicare would go through cuts in his latest “penny plan.” In a meeting with Fox News in June 2023, the Kentucky Republican said “the penny plan utilized to work. It was a 1% cut across the entire board. Currently, it’s a 5%, but it’s throughout every little thing,” consisting of Medicare.

“Rand Paul’s done a lot of researching on this in the past. He utilized to claim if we minimize spending by 1% a year for a number of years, we can get back to a much healthier place,” the Nevada Current short article estimated Brown as saying at a Republican women’s lunch in February. “I have not heard an upgrade on all that with all the investing we’ve had in the last 24 months, however I assume that’s a very sensible place to begin. Just claiming, ‘Hey, allow’s have all the agencies and divisions begin to tighten their belts throughout the board.'”.

In reaction, Scott claimed in a March 2022 meeting that “no person,” including himself, “wants to sunset Medicare or Social Protection,” declaring that he just wanted to begin a debate in Congress on how to “preserve those programs.” In February 2023, when he reintroduced his plan, he included a note claiming it “was never planned to apply to Social Safety and security, Medicare, or the US Navy.”

In its article, the Nevada Current also priced estimate Brown as saying, “A well balanced spending plan modification is additionally something I would certainly support.” Such modifications might trigger deep investing cuts, including to Medicare. In 2013, economic expert Henry J. Aaron of the Urban Brookings Tax obligation Plan Facility advised the House Judiciary Committee that a Republican BBA proposal during that time “would negatively impact the economy and endanger the country’s economic stability.”.

When asked which legislator he “admires the most,” Brown stated he admires Scott for “trying to cast a positive vision” and “attempting to create a roadmap for a better America,” describing Scott’s Strategy to Rescue America.

The narrator in the ad claims, “Sam Brown accepted sunsetting Medicare and Social Safety And Security. Sam Brown openly sustained compeling enormous cuts to Social Protection and Medicare, and was captured on tape claiming he appreciates the strategy to terminate Social Protection and Medicare totally in five years.”

It’s fair game for the Rosen project to criticize Brown for sustaining monetary plans that can possibly place popular programs at risk, consisting of Medicare. It’s inaccurate to say that Brown “accepted sunsetting Medicare and Social Security” or recommend that he supports “the plan to phase out Social Safety and Medicare completely in 5 years.” At this point, not also Scott– the writer of the Strategy to Rescue America– supports subjecting Medicare and Social Security to the sundown requirement.

We asked the Brown campaign how its candidate plans to stabilize the budget without cutting Social Security and Medicare– two programs that are the main vehicle drivers of government budget deficit, as the Congressional Spending plan Office claimed in a June report. But the campaign supplied no substantive answer. Instead, it referred us back to the video clip of Brownish discussing the demand for “better financial policies” without providing any specifics.

“Factor 6” of Scott’s plan, which was classified “federal government reform/debt,” stated, in part: “All federal regulation sundowns in 5 years. If a legislation deserves keeping, Congress can pass it once again.” Social Safety And Security (1935) and Medicare (1965) were developed by legislation, so Scott’s plan was criticized at the time by Democrats and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell for threatening to end both programs.

Sam Brown, the Republican politician Us senate prospect in Nevada, has actually openly supported cutting government spending in ways that experts claim would certainly require deep cuts in popular programs. His Autonomous challenger goes too far in a TV advertisement that claims Brownish “welcomed sunsetting Medicare and Social Security.”

“Look, the Medicare budget plan is a trillion bucks,” he said. “You assume you can not skim off a few percentage without actually reducing health care? I assume you could really do it and improve health care by making Medicare extra reliable, however no one ever before does it. They just say it’s off the table.”.

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not accept advertising and marketing. We rely on grants and private donations from individuals like you. Please consider a contribution. Charge card contributions may be made via our “Contribute” web page. If you like to provide by check, send out to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Law Facility, 202 S. 36th St., Philly, PA 19104.

Brown likewise claimed, like former President Donald Trump, he sustains exempting Social Safety and security advantages from government income tax obligation.” The advertisement plainly states that Sam Brown sustains forcing cuts to Social Safety and Medicare, which is a well-documented effect of a number of economic plans he sustains, including Sen. Rick Scott’s plan that would phase out Social Protection and Medicare in 5 years, which Brown compared to ‘a roadmap for a far better America,’ a GOP balanced spending plan amendment, and his own call to cut government costs ‘across the board,'” the statement checked out. And in each situation, Brown did not state he thought the programs should be excluded from cuts.”

We asked the Rosen campaign for other evidence that Brown, as the television ad claimed, “accepted sunsetting Medicare and Social Protection.” We got a declaration that cited not only Scott’s strategy however other financial policies that Brown has actually supported.

A: Like all power resources, wind farms have some negative environmental influences. Yet getting energy from wind farms leads to dramatically reduced greenhouse gas discharges than obtaining it from nonrenewable fuel sources.

The single source pointed out in the advertisement is the American Journal News, a website operated by True Blue Media LLC and moneyed by Democratic contributors. The site’s “around” page claims, “True Blue Media is a for-profit media business that relies on ad revenue and capitalists, including The American Bridge 21st Century Foundation,” which is a not-for-profit affiliated with the liberal super political action committee American Bridge 21st Century, or AB PAC.

In 2018, when Paul introduced his “Cent Strategy Budget Plan,” the CRFB wrote: “Dime intends tell lawmakers just how much spending to reduce, however they do not give any kind of guidance regarding what programs should be cut.” And, CRFB included, “without those specifics, it’s really tough to see exactly how dramatic spending cuts of this nature are politically or mathematically feasible to attain.”.

“The advertisement clearly states that Sam Brown supports requiring cuts to Social Protection and Medicare, which is a well-documented consequence of a number of financial plans he supports, including Sen. Rick Scott’s strategy that would certainly terminate Social Protection and Medicare in 5 years, which Brown compared to ‘a roadmap for a far better America,’ a GOP balanced budget plan change, and his own contact us to cut government investing ‘across the board,'” the statement checked out. “Analysis has continually located these programs would either require or intimidate large cuts to federal spending, consisting of Social Safety and Medicare. And in each case, Brown did not state he thought the programs ought to be excluded from cuts.”

“This problem is very individual to him, as he has been the beneficiary of Social Protection and Medicare,” Brown project agent Richard Hernandez told us in an email. “He protests cuts to either program.”

“Protecting Social Safety and Medicare is necessary to me,” Brown stated in a current YouTube video that his project sent out to us. “After I was medically relinquished the armed forces, Social Security and Medicare were there for me when I required it most.”

“Negative monetary and financial plans go to the root of most of our problems– if we repair this and have development, we’ll remain in a better location financially and these programs will certainly stay solvent,” Hernandez, Brown’s speaker, told us. “Sam will not allow cuts to Social Safety and security and Medicare.”.

Brown is a retired Military captain that was seriously injured and terribly shed by a roadside bomb in Afghanistan. Some army veterans are eligible to receive gain from the Social Safety And Security Disability Insurance Coverage, or SSDI, and the Supplemental Protection Income, or SSI, programs. Those who receive SSDI for 24 months are automatically qualified to obtain Medicare.

The Aug. 2, 2023, post on the partisan site is based upon remarks Brown made in February 2022 during a monthly meeting of Las vega’ Springtime Hill Republican Politician Women. Brown made no mention in his comments of sunsetting Medicare or Social Security or requiring huge cuts to the programs.

Brown likewise stated, like former Head of state Donald Trump, he sustains exempting Social Safety gain from government income tax obligation. Such a plan would have the web result of boosting benefits for some senior citizens, however it also would certainly raise the federal deficiency unless the income loss is offset. Taxing Social Safety and security advantages elevated $51 billion in profits in 2024, according to the Social Safety And Security Management.

We asked the Brown campaign just how its prospect means to stabilize the budget plan without reducing Social Protection and Medicare– 2 programs that are the major motorists of federal deficiency investing, as the Congressional Budget Workplace stated in a June record. It’s fair game for the Rosen project to slam Brown for sustaining monetary plans that could potentially put preferred programs at risk, consisting of Medicare.

Sen. Rand Paul has been proposing what he has called the “Cent Program” for many years, however the proposals have actually obtained gradually more hostile. As an example, Paul’s “Dime Plan Spending plan” for fiscal year 2019 would certainly have required cuts of 1% annually for five years in optional costs, which leaves out spending on necessary programs such as Medicare and Social Security. A lot more lately, Paul suggested a “Six Penny Plan” for fiscal year 2023 that would certainly have reduced federal costs by 6%, besides Social Protection, every year for 5 years.

“The cuts would certainly have had to apply to nationwide protection, professionals advantages, nourishment aid, Medicare– everything other than Social Security and passion payments,” Aaron indicated. “These cuts or comparable tax obligation increases, it is approximated, would certainly have placed 15 million more people unemployed, increased unemployment from 9 percent to 18 percent, and cut GDP by 17 percent.”.